MEDICAL INSIGHTS · 07

RIBXCAR and rib resection: what is the difference?

Key answer

Resection removes part of a rib; RIBXCAR weakens part of the cortex to change the angle while retaining the bone. RIBXCAR is still surgery involving skin puncture and bone injury. Retaining bone alone cannot guarantee preserved function or fewer complications.

Medical explanation

The distinction in the literature is whether bone is removed or reshaped while retained.

  • Rib resection — An incision provides access, and the planned rib segment is removed.
  • RIBXCAR — Instruments enter through skin punctures under ultrasound guidance. One cortex is weakened to create an incomplete fracture and change the angle. Target ribs, additional maneuvers and brace use depend on anatomy and the surgical plan.

The term “incisionless” in publications does not mean zero skin injury or scarring. Early reports included burns at puncture sites.

The pleura, lungs, intercostal nerves and vessels are nearby, so pneumothorax, hemothorax, pain and healing problems must be considered. Infection and asymmetry also require preoperative discussion. Risk varies with technique, patient factors and how outcomes are observed.

This article compares only RIBXCAR and rib resection. For how it differs from RIBOSS, another method that retains the ribs, see RIBOSS & RIBXCAR: differences and choice.

Evidence

A meta-analysis of 318 patients reported no pneumothorax or hemothorax, but this does not prove zero risk. A later multicenter cohort of 3,805 reported four pneumothoraces, one hemothorax and chronic pain at one-year follow-up. Some persistent-pain cases required subsequent rib resection. Different designs and sample sizes prevent interpreting a simple comparison as rising or falling risk.

Even the large cohort selected women aged 18–45, had no comparison group, and included some additional procedures such as liposuction. These two studies cannot establish superiority in safety over resection or lung function years later.

The technique’s developer also participated in this cohort. Its complication counts describe that study, not the exact risk at another clinic or for an individual.

Questions before a consultation

  • “Not removed” does not mean “unchanged.”
  • Discuss complications, including pneumothorax, and the response plan before surgery.
  • Make the decision knowing that long-term follow-up remains limited.

Related information from da Re-Fit Clinic

References

  1. Manzaneda Cipriani RM, et al. Waist Remodeling without Incision, with Ultrasound-guided Monocortical Fracture. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2023;11(12):e5499. https://doi.org/10.1097/GOX.0000000000005499
  2. Milani-Reis A, Roca Mora MM, Bicudo Bregion P, et al. Rib Remodeling Without Rib Resection: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Aesthetic Plast Surg. 2026;50(2):667-674. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00266-025-05240-w
  3. Manzaneda Cipriani RM, Duran H, Adrianzen GA, et al. A Multicenter Cohort Study of 3805 RibXcar Cases: Safety and Efficacy in Incisionless Rib Remodeling. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open. 2026;14(7):e7929. https://doi.org/10.1097/GOX.0000000000007929

This is general medical information edited against published literature. Literature review and editing are distinct from final physician review and do not replace individual diagnosis or treatment. All procedures carry risks and outcomes vary.